Benny’s Ice Cream

Name: Benny’s Ice Cream
Address: 3040 State Route 28, Old Forge, NY 13420, NY, US
Telephone: (315) 723-4937

3040 State Route 28, Old Forge, NY 13420, , NY|43.709°N · 74.975°W

4 of 4 photos

§ Getting here

Where it sits.

Address

3040 State Route 28, Old Forge, NY 13420
, NY

43.7092°N · 74.9752°W

Drive in from

New York City

266 mi

4h 45m

Albany

119 mi

2h 15m

Boston

273 mi

Montreal

177 mi

3h 15m

Syracuse

93 mi

1h 45m

Buffalo

255 mi

4h 45m

Approximate by-car estimates from the four metros most visitors come from.

§ Make a day of it

Before or after — what's worth pairing with the meal.

Coffee or dessert

Stay the night

Last updated April 29, 2026